The Bone Chests Revealed: New Archaeological Insights from Winchester Cathedral
Review of 'The Bone Chests' by Cat Jarman (2023)
Hello, I’m Holly and I write about the untold tales of medieval lives. Subscribe for free to enjoy regular posts from me, including book reviews, short stories, and historical discussions. Or, even better, join our community of like-minded souls to unlock ALL of my content, including an exclusive serialised historical fiction novel, videos and chats, to open up a world of history as you were never taught it. We’d love you to join us…
This week’s post revisits one of my earliest book reviews by a most favourite author. I have enjoyed both of her popular-level books, watched her on Time Team (have you seen the rebooted series on YouTube? I think it’s fab!) and Digging for Britain, and enjoyed listening to her on podcasts such as History Hit’s Gone Medieval and A Career in Ruins.
Much of what we know about Anglo-Saxon England comes from archaeology, as there just isn’t the same depth of written record as survives for other times and places. I personally love this, because it means that we have to be more creative in our research, whilst dealing with a constantly-evolving body of source material.
This is exactly what Cat deals with in this book. The mortuary chests at Winchester Cathedral are not a new source, but she takes a fresh approach, looking at their contents with new eyes, to ascertain what can be learnt from them.
‘The Winchester mortuary chests and the remains they contain have fascinated visitors to the cathedral for centuries. My intention with this book is to tell the stories of the chests and of the tumultuous times that they, and the people interred within, have found themselves in. Another theme of the book has been to consider why the kingdom of Wessex, and Winchester in particular, took on such significance in the history of England in the early medieval period. For this reason, the emphasis of the book is very much on the south and south-west of England, to the occasional negligence of the rest of the country.’
Jarman, Cat. The Bone Chests: Unlocking the Secrets of the Anglo-Saxons, London: William Collins, 2023, xv.
What is the premise of the book?
The Bone Chests is a history of later Anglo-Saxon England that uses the mortuary chests at Winchester Cathedral as its starting point. It is the tale of England at the time of the individuals named on the chests that Jarman chooses to tell, with additional information on what has happened to them since their original interment. Some were translated to Winchester Cathedral from elsewhere during the Anglo-Saxon age, all were disrupted during the Civil War in the 17th century, and a few have undergone scientific testing in recent years in an attempt to ascertain who the skeletons now in the chests might have been. Hint: there were far more individuals found inside the chests than the names written on the outside would suggest should be there! The real focus of the book, though, is the political history that these individuals (whether or not they have remained in the chests) took part in.
What does it do well?
Each chapter starts with a semi-fictional story of historical characters and their interactions with the mortuary chests. As someone who enjoys writing such tales, I enjoyed the way that Jarman brought the chests to life in this way. I think that historical artefacts are so often seen as static and impersonal, but in reality these chests were made by a real carpenter with a life just like ours, individuals with loves and losses were laid to rest in them, and people with textured lives have admired them over the past 1,000+ years.
This is then blended with a classic political history of later Anglo-Saxon England (although a few earlier characters creep in too!); this forms the bulk of each chapter. Jarman’s interest in the Vikings helps, I think, to shift the balance of popular opinion away from cultural portrayals of the Vikings as the ‘baddies’. She is able to show how the dichotomy of ‘Anglo-Saxon’ vs. ‘Viking’ doesn’t really capture the true interconnectedness of the people ruling at this time; it was much more messy in reality.
What does it not do so well?
As a truly interdisciplinary researcher and writer (straddling archaeology and history as most early Anglo-Saxon students do), I would have liked a bit more focus on the bones and the chests themselves. At times, they felt like a springboard to talk about the political history, being left behind once they had opened the discussion of a particular ruler or time. This may reflect the nature of Jarman’s sources, certainly for the earlier kings she writes about, so I may be asking for something that she would not be able to provide. For me, however, it felt a little like she left the bone chests behind a bit too quickly.
What’s a standout quote or section?
I particularly enjoyed Chapter 5, entitled ‘Conquest’, which included within it the story of Queen Emma. I have always been fascinated by Emma, a woman who married the Anglo-Saxon king Æthelred and, after his death, the Viking king Cnut. She, to me, sums up the interconnectedness that Jarman succeeds in demonstrating: a living, breathing symbol of the interwoven texture of Anglo-Viking relations at this time. I think, also, as a millennial woman, the tale of any strong woman of the past is likely to catch my eye; Emma was, for sure, a strong woman, and Jarman illustrates her story beautifully.
Who should read this book?
Anyone with an interest in later Anglo-Saxon history, from roughly the reign of Alfred (the Great) to the Norman Conquest. Don’t let the archaeological background of Jarman put you off: her use of the archaeological sources to draw political implications means that this book reads most like a history book. Her writing is easy to read and accessible to all, whether you read history books all the time (guilty as charged) or are just dipping your toe in the water.
I hope you enjoyed this post.
To receive more posts like this, become a free subscriber to Telling Their Tales. Even better, to unlock ALL my content, including book chat, videos and instalments of my serialised historical fiction novel, join our paid membership community.
Similar posts you might also enjoy:
Did you know that you can now buy my photos on Etsy?
I photograph the wild and rugged terrain of the countryside across the UK, such as the Lake District, the Peak District, and Eryri (Snowdonia). They are available for digital download at the link below.
Thanks for sharing! I definitely want to read!